Daily Archives: August 29, 2013

Skandera Not Legally Qualified

New Mexico constitution:

Sec. 6. [Public education department;
public education commission.]
A. There is hereby created a “public education
department” and a “public education
commission” that shall have such powers
and duties as provided by law. The
department shall be a cabinet department
headed by a secretary of public education
who is a qualified, experienced educator
who shall be appointed by the governor and
confirmed by the senate.


Skandera does not have any experience in the classroom, but she does have a BS in Political Science.


August 29, 2013 · 6:35 am

Why So Glum?

To paraphrase a question asked of one of my co-workers today- a parent at our school wondered why so many of the teachers, usual sources of good cheer, seem disaffected from the get-go this year.

Poor pay?  Well, most teachers have seen a significant decrease in their pay again this year, yes, but…

Class size?  Well, most teachers at our school are in fact experiencing very large classes again this year, yes, but…

Blah Blah Blah- these are the constant winds blowing in our faces, and we have generally  been able to let them blow by… so what is the proverbial straw that is breaking our back to school?

Teachers are being made to conform to rules set by Hannah Skandera on behalf of Susana Martinez, bureaucratic procedures in the name of accountability, that do nothing to make education better, but will create some awesome busywork for teachers.  The rules are about how teachers are to be evaluated, and were set into place by bypassing the legislature, by someone who cannot get confirmed as the Secretary of Education, because she does not have the legal qualifications for the job.  The teachers’ union filed suit, which was dismissed, and the union seems to be taking no apparent further action.

This is the straw, because teachers feel like they have no recourse.  Many of the teachers at our school, after our first days of these revelations,  had open conversation about other careers or jobs they are considering.    Teachers can then be replaced by script readers of canned curriculum, much less costly to employ, and “teaching” will at last be an hourly job, a stepping stone for more serious career paths.

Teachers want real accountability.  This isn’t it.  This is just a PR stunt.  Have you seen a bad teacher fired?   What about that awesome house cleaning in Rhode Island, where the mayor fired all those “bad apples?”  Nope.  Didn’t happen.  I wonder how much it cost to put on that appearance of reform.  The teacher’s union and APS worked for an alternative evaluation system that passed both the House and Senate last year, and was pocket vetoed by Susana Martinez.  She doesn’t just want reform.  There are major publishing companies making money off of our childrens’ education here in New Mexico, and allegations of corruption are piling up.

Susana Martinez and Hannah Skandera continue to accuse teachers of being comfortable with the status quo, but actually reverting to textbooks and publishers’ standardized tests is the status quo.  In fact, it was the fifties!  Education moved on.  We found that in order to teach innovation, we need to have examples of independent thought in our classrooms.  Innovation is an American value.  Individualism, not corporate group think, is what America was built upon.  Education is about individual dialogue and relationships.

People are worried that teaching is no longer a profession.  This is a national trend.  If there is care for the profession, there should be outrage about the current proclamations from the Governor’s office, which circumvented the legal system.

New Mexico, on Governor Martinez’s watch, has officially hit bottom as a place to raise children.  Number fifty.  Shouldn’t we at least be using our own legal processes to install education policy, rather than just foist it on the public?  Education must be a safe haven from the unscrupulous mixing of public and private funds.  Teaching, the development of curricula and tests, should be done by highly qualified teachers in small classrooms.  All these other smoke and mirrors tactics are just politics.


Filed under Uncategorized

Golden Reflection…

This I sent last night to Brian O’Connell and the folks at Golden Apple, and I thought it was a nice reflection of the trip they so generously afforded me:

Hello Brian, 

So first of all, thanks.  Thanks to you and all the people with Golden Apple who made my trip possible.   Going to the Smithsonians is probably the best place to get all kinds of excellent (free) information, teaching presentation methodology, and materials in many disciplines in a very small geographic area.  I plan to put together my video materials that I made, but that will take some time, of which I am currently, withal, in short supply.

While there, I spoke with Senator Udall, met with his education liaison, met with Michelle Lujan Grisham’s education liaison, spoke with them about the need for there to be a preference for teacher made, not publisher made, curriculum and testing, and sent follow up notes.  I don’t expect there will be a sudden change, or that I even made much of an impression, however, I believe in working to make change.  All listened politely and even to some extent encouraged further activism.  I will continue to do what I can do.

The other thing is, I really needed to be there.  I was there to make amends with our national schizophrenia about public education.  I inventory my own worth as a teacher fairly frequently, and then question the worth of the profession within the technological, political, and economic vectors that constantly influence or disparage the profession.

Some balm for my ennui is the presence of the Smithsonians themselves.  Interspersed with the offices of our government up and down the National Mall are the collection of Smithsonians.  Massive edifices mixed with monuments, our national heroes, these tributes to public education.  Free information, available to all, the DNA of informed democracy.  Of the people, by the people- no qualifier with economics, race, preferences.  This did shore my confidence.  Even though I had read of where I was going, being there was the thing.  I am not a person who is refreshed by the cold stone creations of people; I do much better with a tree than a monument.  Still, the markers placed there to articulate the things We think important are impressive.  The effort spent to record the words of history, the knowledge accumulated and hard lessons learned in science and in history, they do reinforce the values one would hope to be reinforced, and echo the large questions of existence of individual and society, and so, of course, left me with again an echo of ennui.

Back into the classroom then, where the fountain of youth flows for me and my ennui.  Such a great word, just thought I would beat it to death here.  Ennui, ennui, ennui.  Kids, far greater than those monuments, rise above me and lift me up.  Tall kids, you say.  Yes, in their expectation of me and the world, and now with this bit of renown from the Apple, perhaps more.  I shall have to live up to the wide-eyed expectation of children some day.  Meanwhile, I will settle into some chips and salsa, and be glad for their company.  Speaking of, and as you know, my daughters and wife were there for all this.  What a perfect time for them to do to this, at 13.  My daughters, not my wife.  They are twins, methinks you know.  Anyway.  What a thing.  What a great gift, the Golden ticket I was given.  For my whole family, for my students.  For me.  Repetitive, endless, thanks.

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized