The two party system has its flaws, not the least of which is the tendency to polarize. During this time, during any time, if we are going to stand as a nation, North and South, right and left, self and other, we must recognize the need for the opposing point of view. We need to respect the fact that there is a source for the differences, and insist on a reasonable exchange. We cannot win over the “other side” if we threaten them. Name calling- nope. Reason. Tell me why you think that, and let me tell you why I think the way I do. Keep the calm in the storm. Value each other. There are no expendables. Democracy is the ends and the means, and includes all voices. Each of us must insist on all of us.
Monthly Archives: January 2017
In my undergraduate work from 1984 to 1988 at NMSU, I had the privilege of working for the PBS station there, KRWG, doing some video work and editing. I was neither here nor there about politics. I had worked with Jim Laukes, who had done a series of oral interviews, largely focusing on the relationship of the National Labs and NMSU.
In editing some of the “teasers” for the episodes, there was one with Major General Hugh Milton that I remember. There is a statue of General Milton outside of the Journalism building which also carried his name, when I went to school there. This was the Reagan era, and I predicted that General Milton would be all about military might. This was the Cold War, and I was young.
He said, “In a 100 years there has never been such change. Do we understand it? The answer is ‘no’.” In the course of the interview, General Milton put his arm out on the table. In talking about the Cold War build-up he continued…”Our country is hiding its greatest virtue under a bushel. The might of The United States is not in strength of its weapons, but in the promise of freedom”.
It was a moment when my prejudices were exposed, and proven wrong, and I was humbled when I realized it. I think of that now. The great virtue of the promise of freedom.
After all the millions spent on testing, as a state we are educationally and economically worse off than when we began to replace instruction with measurement. The best correlation to a test score remains socioeconomic status, a test score has no correlation to student success, and yet we perseverate knowing that there are significant variables that cannot be captured on a test. The premise of the reform was that having just three good teachers during the course of schooling is a boost to student outcomes, so we went to work evaluating teachers instead of improving their training. If we apply resources at the beginning of the pipeline, rather than the end, we can change things. Rather than pursue this until we are utterly spent, let’s go with what we know works.
- We know that the better educated teachers are, the better the outcomes for students, which is true even before a student begins school. If we improve requirements for teacher education, we improve student outcomes. (1,2)
- We know that if those teachers are paid well enough, they are more likely to stay, and we know that teacher experience increases student performance and attendance. (1, 2)
- We know that professional control of a classroom matters, that micromanagement by policy makers or site administrator is destructive to professional creativity and performance. (Citation pending)
We can end the soft bigotry and hypocrisy of moving resources further and further away from our diverse students while we expect them to test better. We can stop pouring millions out of our state on a course we have shown year after year to be a dead end.
It’s been a couple of years now, since my dad died, and I learned things from him, good and bad, as is done by all people everywhere in all relations- but he would say, in either case, its a “learning experience”, which would turn even the bad into something useful. That’s exactly the kind of platitude that would drive me crazy, but now resonates with me as a mantra in my role as a teacher, parent, spouse, and yet the offspring of someone in this place.
Mom was talking last night with one of my colleagues who just recently completed her PhD, about how she helped dad by typing his many hundreds of pages dissertation. It’s a story like many that I’ve heard many times, which becomes more valuable with each telling, stories like a favorite tune that plays on the last radio station that will play it, that I know I am inexorably getting farther and farther away from.
Today I remembered when one of my father’s professors from Northwestern visited us at my folks’ place. He was into his 90’s, and had been the sole reason my father got his PhD in geology, dad had told me that it was this man’s passion for the subject that gave him his passion for his choice. It was amazing to me that this guy came to visit, so many years later.
I think of this in my own teaching, that beyond the curricula there is the passing of the desire to learn. The modern age of “learning to pass the test” forgets this, in fact betrays this. I think of this quote from Einstein: “It is a very grave mistake to think that the enjoyment of seeing and searching can be promoted by means of coercion and a sense of duty. To the contrary, I believe it would be possible to rob even a healthy beast of prey of its voraciousness, if it were possible, with the aid of a whip, to force the beast to devour continuously, even when not hungry.”.
The passion for living isn’t found in the filling of roles, but in the adventure of life, and the excitement of learning. Learning is not the passing of information, the connections that come together create something new, in each person who makes those discoveries. For me, teaching is about this: the free thinking of people who live in a free society. The passing of that flame is the joy of life, that each person holds infinite possibilities of limitless direction, their own direction, not the learning of skills to fill a spot that was left empty by the cog that wore out before them.
I would like to be as my dad was for me, for my own daughters and students, to encourage their questions as adventures to explore. Life has not been done. It is this, it is happening, and I hope to feel its pulse and pass that connection. A new year’s toast, then, to the dead, and then to drink from life in their honor.